A Washington state retrogaming enthusiast has lost almost his entire software library after burglars broke into his home and stole over 860 Nintendo Entertainment System cartridges.
Puyallup resident Roger Holler discovered the theft upon returning from a family trip on a Sunday evening. Intruders had forced entry into the residence and completely cleared out the display shelving that housed nearly 40 years of video game history.
The stolen collection carries an estimated market value ranging from $50,000 to $100,000. Holler was just three games away from completing a full licensed library for the classic console. Beyond the financial loss, the emotional impact has been severe. Holler described experiencing physical distress when looking at the empty shelf, while his son, Chris Sterling, lamented seeing a lifelong family passion abruptly taken away.
Holler’s journey began at age 11 when his mother gave him his first NES console. The hobby grew into a shared family activity, taking father and son across Washington to local stores and gaming conventions. Holler had intended to preserve the collection for his grandchildren, hoping it might eventually serve as a financial asset to help cover their college tuition.
The incident highlights the booming commercial value of vintage video games. Classic Nintendo titles continue to command high prices among collectors, as demonstrated in June when Heritage Auctions sold a sealed Super Mario Bros. cartridge for $3 million. That same event featured a rare copy of The Legend of Zelda that brought in $375,000, contributing to an auction total exceeding $5 million.
The theft also illustrates the vulnerabilities of physical game collecting. While tangible media protects against digital store shutdowns and shifts like Sony's plan to end disc production by 2028, physical items remain susceptible to burglary. Today, gamers looking for alternative access to retro classics rely on digital offerings such as Nintendo Switch Online.
About the Author
